‘ALW included’ 😂 i mean…yeah.

peremadeleine:

“The Phantom’s story works…due to one simple fact: Christine doesn’t love the Phantom. Throughout both the novel and the musical, she sees the Phantom as a guardian spirit, her “Angel of Music”, more akin to a mentor and father figure than a romantic interest. Her romantic feelings are only awakened by the return of her childhood sweetheart, Raoul, and the ensuing conflict stems from their inability to reciprocate their affections due to the Phantom’s influence. Whether Raoul is an appealing or interesting character is beside the point–she loves him, and not Erik. Despite his obsession with her, he’s a father figure at best, an abusive psychological tormentor at worst. Christine admires the man for his musical genius, pities the tragedy that forced him to such violent desperation, but fears the lengths he’ll undergo to win her. While she does appear somewhat open to his seductions in “Music of the Night”, there’s never a doubt she’ll choose Raoul over him. Her attraction to him is not romantic or sexual, but rather admiration of his musical ability, and pity for the disfigurement that ruined his life and distorted his character. Erik, again, is a mentor, a father figure (albeit in a twisted sort of way, using her love for her father to manipulate her), Raoul her childhood sweetheart, a man her own age who proves he loves and cares for her on multiple occasions, not the least in risking death to free her from the Phantom’s clutches. Considering Erik has lied to her, impersonated her father in order to seduce her, murdered innocent people and kidnapped her twice, it’s no real surprise that in the end she refuses to succumb to him, instead stepping out from his shadow and regaining her own agency.”

—

Phantom of the Opera and the Problem of “Shipping” by Allie Dawson [x]

This article isn’t without its flaws (and of course people are going to ship what they want regardless of canon), but I loved seeing this stated in plain, unequivocal black-and-white since everyone and their brother (ALW included) romanticizes the heck out of Erik and his behavior and pretends like Christine, the young woman whom he manipulates, terrorizes, and victimizes regularly for years, somehow “belongs” with him romantically. tl;dr I think this article makes some solid arguments about Phantom as a story, particularly the nature of love and both Christine and Erik’s arcs in said story.